Comments on: Good design, when done well, becomes invisible http://www.inspireux.com/2009/01/21/good-design-when-done-well-becomes-invisible/ User Experience quotes and articles to inspire and connect the UX community Wed, 08 Feb 2012 10:47:32 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v= By: El buen diseño… | Blog Image & Web Solution http://www.inspireux.com/2009/01/21/good-design-when-done-well-becomes-invisible/comment-page-1/#comment-2504 El buen diseño… | Blog Image & Web Solution Sat, 24 Jan 2009 00:19:54 +0000 http://www.inspireux.com/?p=493#comment-2504 [...] [vía inspireUX] [...] [...] [vía inspireUX] [...]

]]> By: Catriona http://www.inspireux.com/2009/01/21/good-design-when-done-well-becomes-invisible/comment-page-1/#comment-2474 Catriona Wed, 21 Jan 2009 18:07:34 +0000 http://www.inspireux.com/?p=493#comment-2474 Good point, Dave. The quote really does have to be taken in a larger context. If you go into the source article, Jared points out: "Few people come to a web page to admire its visual design. However, poor visual design is really noticeable and takes the user away from their task. While we often think of visual design in terms of page aesthetics, the real crime comes when it’s the visual structure that gets in the way." So, really, he means that good design isn't necessarily "invisible" but that good design shouldn't get in the way of accomplishing your task. That doesn't mean the design shouldn't be engaging or even noticable. Good point, Dave. The quote really does have to be taken in a larger context. If you go into the source article, Jared points out:

“Few people come to a web page to admire its visual design. However, poor visual design is really noticeable and takes the user away from their task. While we often think of visual design in terms of page aesthetics, the real crime comes when it’s the visual structure that gets in the way.”

So, really, he means that good design isn’t necessarily “invisible” but that good design shouldn’t get in the way of accomplishing your task. That doesn’t mean the design shouldn’t be engaging or even noticable.

]]> By: Dave Malouf http://www.inspireux.com/2009/01/21/good-design-when-done-well-becomes-invisible/comment-page-1/#comment-2469 Dave Malouf Wed, 21 Jan 2009 15:15:22 +0000 http://www.inspireux.com/?p=493#comment-2469 While I understand the intention of the quote and the quoter, I think when taken out of context as a sound bite becomes disingenuous. Design is powerful and when done well is NOT invisible at all. It may not be called "design" or "bad design" when done well, but it is noticed. The visceral response of looking at a Porche Cayman or a BMW 7 series is definitely felt and noticed. the unpackaging experience of an iPod is not unnoticed or invisible, nor is that first use of an iPhone. What is dangerous in leaving the quote in isolation without contextualizing it further is that it leaves possible readers with the thoughts that invisibility is the real goal, which is not. Engagement in many design contexts is an important goal and to engage the user must feel like they are engaging with something real and tangible and NOT invisible. They WANT to use the clickwheel, physical scrolling, and wii gestural interfaces. They will notice these interface points and often articulate their use and bring their concepts into their everyday speech. -- dave While I understand the intention of the quote and the quoter, I think when taken out of context as a sound bite becomes disingenuous. Design is powerful and when done well is NOT invisible at all. It may not be called “design” or “bad design” when done well, but it is noticed. The visceral response of looking at a Porche Cayman or a BMW 7 series is definitely felt and noticed. the unpackaging experience of an iPod is not unnoticed or invisible, nor is that first use of an iPhone.

What is dangerous in leaving the quote in isolation without contextualizing it further is that it leaves possible readers with the thoughts that invisibility is the real goal, which is not. Engagement in many design contexts is an important goal and to engage the user must feel like they are engaging with something real and tangible and NOT invisible. They WANT to use the clickwheel, physical scrolling, and wii gestural interfaces. They will notice these interface points and often articulate their use and bring their concepts into their everyday speech.

– dave

]]> By: Mokokoma Mokhonoana http://www.inspireux.com/2009/01/21/good-design-when-done-well-becomes-invisible/comment-page-1/#comment-2460 Mokokoma Mokhonoana Wed, 21 Jan 2009 12:47:34 +0000 http://www.inspireux.com/?p=493#comment-2460 I totally agree, more esp. in regards to user-interface design! I totally agree, more esp. in regards to user-interface design!

]]>